Are you ready for this? I have found my Holy Grail Cleanser for wintertime!
Lancome's Galatee Confort Comforting Milky Cream Cleanser - Ta DA! It comes in 2 sizes: 6.8 oz. for $27, and 13.5 oz. for $43.50 - both sizes in pump bottles. Does not contain any no-no's for stingers like me. I don't know about how it removes makeup since I don't wear any, but it feels instantly soothing on the skin. Can be rinsed or tissued off. I can spray my face with distilled H2O and wipe off. Fragrance is at the bottom of the ingredient list, but the fragrance is not cloying and dissipates with product removal. And I'm really bothered by fragrances! I was clued in to this product many years ago when it was used on my face at an in-store makeover. But I had oily skin at the time, so I couldn't use it on a regular basis. Things are different now, however. Galatee leaves the skin really soft and smooth. No toner is necessary. See all my picks in another post.
Inky